Nazis Let You Do Anything

Nazis Let You Do Anything
I read somewhere that Nazis make the best video game villains.You see, the hero needs to be able to slaughter endless hordes of anonymous bad guys. But, for any game set in vaguely present-day Earth, it's hard to pick a horde one can endlessly slaughter without complaint. Someone -- probably someone you'd like to sell games to -- will be understandably offended. But Nazis? You can do anything you want to Nazis! Kill 'em, roast 'em, cook 'em in a stew ... who cares? They're Nazis!There was something else I wrote a long time ago -- initially I thought as a very old blog post, but now I'm thinking it may have been an actual essay I wrote for a college seminar -- where I described the Holocaust and World War II more generally as a "moral black hole." By that term, I meant that the Holocaust was such an extreme event that it warps the fabric of morality itself. The normal rules of moral physics don't work there. To try to resolve supposed moral dilemmas like Sophie's Choice, Simon Wiesenfeld's The Sunflower, or the starving camp inmate who steals bread from another inmate to survive -- it can't be done, and it's a mistake to even try. It will not work, and the effort to make it work can only corrupt the normal moral order.I was thinking about these two ideas in relation to a way in which "Nazi" is sometimes used in contemporary political discourse. A way, not the way. I'm not here to say that all invocations of Nazi Germany in contemporary political discourse, not even all those I may think are too loose or unwarranted, fit the template I'm about to lay out. In particular, I'm not talking about persons who compare the ascendent threat of right-wing authoritarianism embodied in the MAGA movement to the rise of the Third Reich. That comparison -- whether justified or not -- is a historical analogy that relies on normal practices of historical argument and evidence.But there is another, distinctive way "Nazi" is being used right now that to my ears at least is becoming increasingly common, and feels distinctively problematic. To wit: some people seem attracted to Nazi comparisons for the freedom they license -- a permission slip to step outside the normal code, an allowance for conduct or behavior or activity that otherwise would seem obviously beyond the pale. "Nazi" macht frei.I'll give two examples, on opposing sides of the political ledger. I have seen people, upon being shown images of a bombed out Gaza Strip, respond by showing similar images of bombed out Berlin or Dresden. They who see the Hamas regime in Gaza as analogous to a Nazi state will talk about the firebombing of German cities or the hellish conditions that befell Europe during the war and ask, if it was okay there, when the allies were fighting to destroy Nazi Germany, why is it suddenly not okay here? We "bounced rubble" to destroy Nazis once, we can do it again, and let nobody mourn the Nazi's complete and utter destruction.My answer -- or one of my answers, anyway -- is that every inch of global authority in the development of the post-war order, including but not limited to the developments in the law of war, was dedicated to trying to ensure that a hell as complete as World War II never happened again. Particularly in the nuclear era, it's far from clear that the world could survive such a fury again. I won't sit here in 2026 and pass judgment on what needed to be done to win World War II. I will say that World War II was such an extreme and extraordinary horror that it is perhaps the worst possible model for contemporary morality. World War II's extremity warps our moral physics beyond recognition. That prospect should not attract us; we should resist with every fiber of our being having to return to that space.Of course, there are others for whom the Nazi analogy applies in the other direction. For them, it is the Israelis that are the Nazis, and as Nazis, they wonder, why should anyone mourn anything that happens to them as anything other than ecstatic karmic deserts? Do we pass judgment on how the desperate men and women of the Warsaw Ghetto fought? Do we care that they may have hidden in homes or used children as messengers? For that matter, who would even shed a tear if patrons of a Nazi music festival, dancing at the edges of the ghetto, were overrun by soldiers breaking out of prison -- killed, raped, or taken hostage? They're Nazis -- do what you want to them.In either case, the appeal of the "Nazi" comparison lies in how it frees one from constraint. Note that this isn't quite the same as the old "everyone you don't like is a Nazi" complaint. It's more complex than just seeing the appeal of "Nazi" as name-calling. And it's also distinct from even a (stipulate for sake of argument) "bad" comparison warning that such-and-such policy by the Trump administration is reminiscent of some Nazi law or practice. The problem is not one of simply making bad analogies. The problem is, again, the use of "Nazi" to burst free of the moral constraints which one would normally accept as binding and constraining, but which fall apart when one's enemy is a Nazi. The player who might recoil at casually and cruelly slaughtering thousands can take unalloyed satisfaction in doing it to Nazis; the observer who might pale at the site of entire cities reduced to utter decimation can instead feel joy knowing that they were Nazi cities; the critic who would viscerally feel the terror of a teenager kidnapped from a concert can instead exult that it happened to a Nazi. What Nazi does here is it allows the normal hard work of moral inquiry -- just causes limited by just means, and vice versa -- can yield to the exhilarating freedom of being able to do anything. No more thought is required, no deliberation, no balancing of interests, no recognition of common humanity -- none of that is necessary (or even desirable) when we're dealing with Nazis.I don't think this is healthy. It should go without saying that the norm -- the very strong norm -- should be in favor of mutual recognition of common humanity, of the importance of moral restraints even in times of war, occupation, or any number of even extraordinary abuses and immoralities. Again, I have no interest in litigating whether World War II "justified" departure from the normal moral rules; but again, I will stress that to the extent WWII did require such a departure in the face of an unprecedented existential catastrophe that necessity is horrific and awful and in no way a desirable state of affairs to enter into. Yet I fear that too many people, with varying degrees of explicitness, thirst for the freedom that this extremity provides. "Nazi" comparisons are their shorthand to get to that space -- and it is a very bad space to be in.

Take Your Experience to the Next Level

New

Download our mobile app for a faster and better experience.

Comments

0
U

Join the discussion

Sign in to leave a comment

0:000:00